Beefcake Bakeshop presents a tit-for-tat pie fight video between two studs, featuring dialog and some slapstick sound effects. Musclestooge wants to get even with his friend, Pete, who's a taller, handsome, square jawed, man. So, he invites him out to a nice dinner. They get dressed up in trousers, dress shirts, and ties. But before they go, Musclestooge reminds Pete that he's done him wrong, and hits his friend in the face with a sticky pie. Musclestooge thinks they're even now. Wrong! Pete escalates things and counters with a pie to Musclestooge's crotch, then shirt, messing up his clothes. So Musclestooge does the same to Pete, messing up his shirt and rubbing it in. This escalates to some pies smashed in each other's faces. Pete undoes Musclestooge's shirt and plants a pie on his bare chest and rubs it into his meaty pecs. Pete pulls Musclestooge's pants down, revealing humiliating briefs. Standing there in embarrassment, Musclestooge has whipped cream squirted into his underwear, which Pete massages in thoroughly. Musclestooge reciprocates, leaving Pete in his funny boxers, and smashes a pie to his crotch. He reaches through the fly and gives Pete a thorough fondling, as he stands there with pie dripping off his face. Although humiliated, could they actually be getting turned on!? Perhaps, but they continue to hit each other with more pies. When Musclestooge taunts Pete to hit him "right in the kisser," Pete takes the opportunity, leans in and they embrace in a hot, messy kiss. Completely pied and standing there in their bulging underwear--truce!